Thanks for all the thoughtful replies. Badly edited books are a huge pet peeve of mine. I definitely note that in the review, almost always giving specific examples. I find the "your/you're" and "their/they're/there" are some of the most common errors I see, along with comma neglect/abuse and poorly formatted sentences (fragments/run-ons). I also dislike reviews that give me a play-by-play of the book, and especially get frustrated with spoilers.
Caleb- I know what you mean about the differences in spelling and such with US/AU/UK. I tend to really enjoy reading books that are written from a different language point of view, but some things throw me off (most notably, single quotes for speaking).
Quote:
Originally Posted by Billi
GraceKrispy, this is perhaps the least helpful answer, but I was just visiting your blog and I like the way you're reviewing books.
*SNIP*
Do you review every book you get - regardless of it's quality - or is it a kind of praise for the book if it is reviewed on your blog?
|
Thanks, that's very kind!
I have pretty eclectic tastes, so I am willing to try most books sent to me directly by authors. If they have put time and effort into writing and marketing the book, and it sounds remotely interesting, I'll give it a shot. I have been pleasantly surprised several times. I have turned down a number of review requests, however. If I truly feel I won't get into the book, or the request email was riddled with the type of errors we are discussing on this thread, then I politely decline.
If I read the book, I review it. Some books have gotten 1.5-2 stars on my blog. I don't ascribe to the concept of only reviewing books I rated highly; I feel that's doing a disservice to the reader as well as the author.
If generic queries are sent via a publisher, I tend to only request a review copy if it *really* interests me.