Late to the party, but for what it's worth, I have the Qwest (matte) on my Kindle 3 and the hubby has Josei 2 (matte) on his Kindle. I have Bicycle Chain (high gloss) on my Nook with the matching screen saver.
Despite it being an extra $5, I LOVE the matte finish and regret purchasing the glossy one for the Nook. The matte finish seems to apply easier (in my experience), doesn't pick up finger prints, feels nicer to hold for any significant length of time (less slippery) and (most importantly) there's no glare when using a booklight.
My husband both use
this case for our Kindles and they look great in it.