MobileRead Forums - MobileRead December 2016 Book Club Vote

Page 2 of 3

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

MobileRead Forums (https://www.mobileread.com/forums/index.php)

- Book Clubs (https://www.mobileread.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=245)

- - MobileRead December 2016 Book Club Vote (https://www.mobileread.com/forums/showthread.php?t=281173)

JSWolf

12-01-2016 05:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by issybird (Post 3436415)

I read Handmaid's Tale when it came out, so decades later, I figure it can stand a re-read. I have zero interest in reading YA for a book club discussion. I've said so before. :D According to the publisher, it's at a fourth grade reading level. Give me a break, honestly. I like kidlit when it comes with a kid. Not for a group of adults.

I've read The Handmaid's Tale and I would rather read something more upbeat.

I've read some good YA books and I'm not bothered to read more. Besides, I think he term You cannot be a YA. You are not a young adult. You are an adult or not.

issybird

12-01-2016 05:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JSWolf (Post 3436422)

Well, I agree that someone in the fourth grade isn't a young adult; he's a kid. I really do like children's literature; I just don't think it makes for a good discussion. Next up, we'll be talking about whether Junie B. was justified in being scared of the school bus. :p

I do take your point about Handmaid's Tale.

CRussel

12-01-2016 07:26 PM

The Riordan book is just aimed too young for me. So I passed. I am reading The Handmaid's Tale, but suspect from the comments that I may not finish it. So far, it's not going where I want to go, though it is starting to pull me in. I voted, but doubt any of my choices will make the cut, even for a runoff.

Yes, I know Sharon Lee's book is not available at the library. I think that's unfortunate, but the book is only $6.99, and IS eligible for any Kobo coupons you might have. And it's not dark.

Dazrin

12-01-2016 07:27 PM

Since several people have already read it, is there a fantasy element* to Handmaid's Tale? All of the blurbs and reviews I have read are clear on dystopian (which is normally science fiction, not fantasy) but I don't see "fantasy" in any of them. Just imagining what the future could be like under an extreme fundamentalist "totalitarian theocracy" doesn't make it a fantasy novel. Unless there is something, it seems like this doesn't really meet the topic for this month.

Even Atwood's comments seem to say they are science fiction (under the speculative fiction umbrella) and not fantasy.

Quote:

I have written two works of science fiction or, if you prefer, speculative fiction: The Handmaid's Tale and Oryx and Crake.

*Magic, supernatural events, elves, fairies, or just the "unexplainable and mysterious".

JSWolf

12-01-2016 09:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CRussel (Post 3436509)

Yes, I know Sharon Lee's book is not available at the library. I think that's unfortunate, but the book is only $6.99, and IS eligible for any Kobo coupons you might have. And it's not dark.

Nominate this book next time it is appropriate and I will give it a nod and if it makes it, a vote.

JSWolf

12-01-2016 09:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dazrin (Post 3436510)

Yes, you are correct. It's not fantasy. It's not something I thought of at the time. I think it should be disqualified.

Dazrin

12-02-2016 12:37 AM

27 minutes to go is anyone going to help us get a Fantasy book for the Fantasy month?

Only time will tell...

WT Sharpe

12-02-2016 07:53 AM

Well, the poll is over and The Handmaid's Tale won, despite not being a fantasy tale in the ordinary sense. I never read the book, but I saw the movie and it's not something I was in the mood to visit as a book, but oh, well.

WT Sharpe

12-02-2016 08:03 AM

My library's only e-copy is loaned out, but fortunately the Kindle price is only $2.99, and Audible narration c an be added for only $3.99 more.

issybird

12-02-2016 10:02 AM

I always thought I'd re-read this someday; the day has come, apparently.

I wonder if I'll find it as compelling as I did 30 years ago? Dystopias litter the landscape now.

JSWolf

12-02-2016 10:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by issybird (Post 3436802)

I always thought I'd re-read this someday; the day has come, apparently.

I wonder if I'll find it as compelling as I did 30 years ago? Dystopias litter the landscape now.

It is a good book. But it's not one I want to reread.

issybird

12-02-2016 11:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JSWolf (Post 3436807)

It is a good book. But it's not one I want to reread.

I almost never want to reread; I missed out on two discussions this year because I didn't feel like rereading, but couldn't remember them well enough to discuss.

JSWolf

12-02-2016 03:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by issybird (Post 3436846)

I almost never want to reread; I missed out on two discussions this year because I didn't feel like rereading, but couldn't remember them well enough to discuss.

I find that sometimes when you do reread, the book comes back to you. So maybe you won't have to reread completely.

I'm going to try to find this as an audiobook. I already have the eBook. I don't remember it well enough to discuss.

CRussel

12-02-2016 04:13 PM

There definitely is an audiobook version. It's even whispersync'd. Read by Claire Danes. I think I'm going to read it as an audiobook as well. Though I have 34 hours of David Weber to finish first.

JSWolf

12-02-2016 04:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CRussel (Post 3436984)

There definitely is an audiobook version. It's even whispersync'd. Read by Claire Danes. I think I'm going to read it as an audiobook as well. Though I have 34 hours of David Weber to finish first.

Yes, it is an audiobook but none of the libraries I use have it as an audiobook. Also, Hoopla does not have it. So I'm not sure if I will reread. But I can make one comment now.

It should not be the book for December as it is not fantasy.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:18 PM.

Page 2 of 3

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page