![]() |
March 2016 Book Club Vote
March 2016 MobileRead Book Club Vote
Help us choose a book as the March 2016 eBook for the MobileRead Book Club. The poll will be open for 5 days. There will be no runoff vote unless the voting results a tie, in which case there will be a 3 day run-off poll. This is a visible poll: others can see how you voted. It is http://wtsharpe.com/Pictures/Multiple-Choice_C3.gif You may cast a vote for each book that appeals to you. We will start the discussion thread for this book on March 20th. Select from the following Official Choices with three nominations each: • Starfish by Peter Watts Patricia Clark Memorial Library: ePub | Kindle Spoiler:
• Under the Red Robe by Stanley Weyman Patricia Clark Memorial Library: ePub | Kindle Spoiler:
• The Phantom of the Opera by Gaston Leroux Patricia Clark Memorial Library: ePub | Kindle | LRF Spoiler:
• The Night Life of the Gods by Thorne Smith Patricia Clark Memorial Library: ePub | Kindle Spoiler:
• A Drama in Muslin by George Moore Patricia Clark Memorial Library: ePub | Kindle Spoiler:
• Music of the Spheres by Wander Bonanno Patricia Clark Memorial Library: ePub | Kindle Spoiler:
|
This is extraordinary. At this point, eight people have voted, and seven have voted for Thorne Smith.
|
Quote:
|
It wasn't on my list, but I haven't voted yet. Still thinking about them. Nothing's really crying out to me, I admit.
|
One more day to vote!
Time to drum up some more support if you don't want to read Night Life of the Gods or pile on if it sounds good. |
Hmm, it's too late now, but in fact, The Night Life of the Gods was not eligible this month, as it was last a nominee in October 2015, five months ago, and we have a six months rule.
I got curious, because I know it's been up for consideration more than once before and I checked. This is the fourth time it's made it to the vote and the most recent, as I said, made it ineligible for this month. Oh well, perhaps it's a good thing that we'll finally be putting this baby to rest! |
issy, please don't bother us with the facts!
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Of course, we could follow the rules, make The Night Life of Gods gone and go from there with the votes the other books have. That would make more sense given that this book is ineligible.
|
I am with issybird, let's get this over with :)
|
I think the statute of limitations ran out on this, Jon.
|
Agreed. If we'd realized before the voting was nearly done we could have disqualified it. But given where we're at, and given that so many have (finally) decided they want to read it, I think it needs to stay in.
|
Whooops! :o
I didn't remember this being nominated before when I nominated it and I was fairly sure I had seen it in the Mobileread Library Recommendations thread but I don't see it there now. Sorry for the error (but I am glad it is staying and winning!) |
Well, there are two options and allowing it to remain should not be one of them since that would make three options and we only have two options.
Option 1: remove the book from the voting list and go with the list as it is with the votes for the rest Option 2: start a new thread with a new poll with this book removed It's unfair if it wins and becomes the book for March. If we are going to violate the rules, then let's violate all the rules. So really, let's not violate the rules knowingly since leaving this book will knowingly violate the rules. |
Quote:
Jon, it's obvious you're upset and I'm sorry. It's all just for fun. You did vote for the potential winner, after all; you must have thought you'd like reading it, even if you'd prefer a different choice. There's no point in discussing your options, which are far from the only choices and result in either disenfranchising people who voted in good faith or making a lot more work for Tom and to what end? People have chosen the book they prefer and it's neither fattening nor illegal. My apologies to everyone else, too. I didn't mean to start anything. I was just, as I tried to indicate, highly amused both that a book could be nominated four times and that it would slip through the cracks in terms of the waiting period. As I said, time to scratch the itch! If it wins, it can never be nominated again. |
Quote:
But, I hope I will recognize it next time given that I maintain the list... |
I'm not upset. But I do think it's unfair for the other books nominated.
What would you suggest if this book was found not to have an eBook version (I know this is not the case)? Would you suggest it be removed from the voting list? My feeling is that if a book is found to be violating the rules and the voting is not over then that book should be removed to keep withing the rules since there is still time for it to be removed. I did vote for it and still think it's going is a good idea. |
Quote:
Maybe we need to keep a list of all the fully nominated works each month in the selections list thread? I don't want to do that but I would link to it in the selections thread if someone else thinks it is necessary and wants to maintain it. Personally, I think that we have done a fairly good job with policing it informally (despite this oops) and making it formal is unnecessary. |
Quote:
I do think a link to the past six months of nominated eBooks would be a good idea. Then we can do our own policing of that. |
Quote:
Like I said, if you want to make and maintain a 6-month list I would add that to the selections list thread, you could put it in that thread if you wanted. I keep the selection list updated with links to all of the nomination/vote threads, so it shouldn't take too much time to create one (or to check them without the list). |
Quote:
|
The poll is closed, and a winner has been chosen. And as it is clear that the majority has no desire to start the nomination and voting procedure over from scratch in order to recover from an unfortunate mistake, happy reading! The Night Life of the Gods by Thorne Smith it is.
|
Quote:
|
I've started and it's delightfully witty. I enjoyed Topper and always meant to get to this, so, no matter by what skullduggery, I'm glad it was chosen. Finally! I've been touring it around on my gadgets since its first nomination. :D
|
downloaded and transferred to my Kindle. But it needs to wait in line for a few more days.
|
March 2016 Book Club Vote
I managed to get my hands on a copy of the 1935 movie based on the book. It's really close to the book with one glaring exception. The following spoiler reveals something from chapter 2:
Spoiler:
Back to the movie: Gilbert Emery's performance as Betts the butler has convinced me Stephen Fry is a time traveler. Emery couldn't have done a better impression of Fry's Reginald Jeeves if he tried, which is remarkable considering he died 12 years before Fry was born. Not only does Emery act like Fry, in this film he even looks remarkably like Fry. |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:32 PM. |
Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 3.8.5, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
MobileRead.com is a privately owned, operated and funded community.