|
View Poll Results: Copyright violation? | |||
Yes, it is a copyright violation even though the IP isn't protected in Canada and the source is Canadian. | 15 | 24.59% | |
It is not a violation. | 28 | 45.90% | |
Not sure | 18 | 29.51% | |
Voters: 61. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
03-17-2010, 01:32 PM | #1 |
Guru
Posts: 612
Karma: 7511929
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: New York, NY
Device: Amazon Kindle Paperwhite 2
|
Books copyright protected in US but not Canada
The US has longer copyright protection so there are a lot of books protected in the US but not in Canada, such as "1984".
As an American who is located in America, can I argue that downloading a book like "1984" is legitimate if the website in question is based in Canada or is from a Canadian "source"? If I drove to Canada, photocopied a paper version of the book, and then drove back to the US, I don't think I would be in violation of the copyright. Or would importing the work be a violation of the copyright? Assuming this isn't a violation, then I think downloading the digital version of the book from a Canadian source should be ok. What do you think? Last edited by markbot; 03-17-2010 at 01:34 PM. |
03-17-2010, 01:43 PM | #2 |
Booklegger
Posts: 1,801
Karma: 7999816
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Device: BeBook(1 & 2010), PEZ, PRS-505, Kobo BT, PRS-T1, Playbook, Kobo Touch
|
An interesting question, especially since I am working on creating an EPUB version of Jim Kjelgaard's Big Red for upload to MR. I know I'm not in trouble, but if you Americans download it, might you be?
You would have to have a court case to decide it. Do you really want to know? Our opinions don't count, you know. |
Advert | |
|
03-17-2010, 01:57 PM | #3 |
Karma Kameleon
Posts: 2,934
Karma: 26616647
Join Date: Aug 2009
Device: iPad Mini, iPhone X, Kindle Fire Tab HD 8, Walmart Onn
|
I imagine that if you are a US citizen you are bound by US laws. If you went to Amsterdam to buy heroin, you couldn't then just bring it back with you. So while you are in the US, you can't do "US illegal things" from your computer even if the server is in a foreign country.
But IANAL Lee |
03-17-2010, 02:36 PM | #4 | |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 5,185
Karma: 25133758
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: SF Bay Area, California, USA
Device: Pocketbook Touch HD3 (Past: Kobo Mini, PEZ, PRS-505, Clié)
|
Quote:
*Distributing* unauthorized copies is forbidden; *acquiring* them is not. AFAIK, you break no laws in downloading *anything*, even if it's entirely under copyright everywhere in the world. However, the uploader could be guilty of copyright infringement in a country he's not a resident of, by making it available to you. Encouraging out-of-country downloads to places where the material is copyrighted, could be seen as inciting a crime. (Not sure if cross-country copyright infringement has been prosecuted. DMCA violations have been prosecuted on non-US citizens whose "crimes" took place in countries where they were not crimes, but DRM tech was involved, not unauthorized copies.) |
|
03-17-2010, 02:42 PM | #5 | |
Addict
Posts: 214
Karma: 511602
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: BC, Canada
Device: Aluratek Libre
|
Same disclaimer: Not a lawyer.
Elfwreck is correct. At least, I'm certain that's how it is in Canada, and I'm fairly sure it's the same in the states. Only the party making the new copy of the file, which is considered to be the uploader and not the downloader, is guilty of piracy. (Much like a person buying a counterfeit is not guilty of counterfeit -- only the one who made it is.) Of course, you would need to make sure that you're downloading the files in such a way that you're not uploading or sharing them in addition to the download. Quote:
The key difference is that the courts up here probably wouldn't recognize the copyright at all, so copyright infringement may not be possible. |
|
Advert | |
|
03-17-2010, 02:45 PM | #6 | |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 19,832
Karma: 11844413
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Tampa, FL USA
Device: Kindle Touch
|
Quote:
BTW: Downloading a file is basically the act of COPYing the file from a server to your PC. So, I'm not sure why only the "uploader" is the one that copied the file. BOb |
|
03-17-2010, 02:46 PM | #7 | |
eBook Enthusiast
Posts: 85,544
Karma: 93383043
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: UK
Device: Kindle Oasis 2, iPad Pro 10.5", iPhone 6
|
Quote:
To answer the original question: you are, strictly speaking, violating copyright in downloading a book that is in copyright in your country, but in the public domain in the place that you download it from. However, if it's for your personal use, your chances of being prosecuted for doing so are zero. |
|
03-17-2010, 03:02 PM | #8 |
Guru
Posts: 612
Karma: 7511929
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: New York, NY
Device: Amazon Kindle Paperwhite 2
|
Were the people who were sued for MP3 sued because of downloading or uploading? I will check this out.
|
03-17-2010, 03:05 PM | #9 |
Guru
Posts: 612
Karma: 7511929
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: New York, NY
Device: Amazon Kindle Paperwhite 2
|
http://www.webopedia.com/DidYouKnow/...ownloading.asp
Based on this article it would seem that the act of copying digital IP that you don't already own is illegal...although doesn't completely answer my question since the IP in question is located in Canada where it is legal to copy it!!! |
03-17-2010, 03:16 PM | #10 | |
Addict
Posts: 214
Karma: 511602
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: BC, Canada
Device: Aluratek Libre
|
Quote:
|
|
03-17-2010, 03:22 PM | #11 |
Guru
Posts: 787
Karma: 1575310
Join Date: Jul 2009
Device: Moon+ Pro
|
Copyright law, in the US at least, starts with the basic premise that the act of making a copy, without the copyright holders permission, is illegal. There are specific exceptions written into the law, but if your situation doesn't fit into one of those exceptions, then the act of making the copy is illegal. (IANAL but I've talked to some about this. This isn't legal advice though, just my interpretation of what they told me.)
As with geographic restrictions, US law considers the site of the 'sale' of a downloaded product to be the location of the person downloading it-so the US downloader of the Canadian PW book would be in violation of US law. (Unless they downloaded it while in Canada, and then bringing it back into the US would be a Customs matter, I think.) On the practical side, it's handled like the war against drugs-both distributing & using are illegal, but they prefer to charge, or sue, the distributors when they can find them. That doesn't prevent them from charging or suing the users because failure to sue (or at least threaten a lawsuit) when an infringer is found can cause loss of copyright. (Just as failure to charge a drug user, when caught, can cause law enforcement to be themselves sued for corruption. Not all charges are prosecuted, nor are all threats of lawsuits carried out-that can be a practical consideration, but the 'gesture' must at least be made.) |
03-17-2010, 03:36 PM | #12 | |
Grand Sorcerer
Posts: 5,185
Karma: 25133758
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: SF Bay Area, California, USA
Device: Pocketbook Touch HD3 (Past: Kobo Mini, PEZ, PRS-505, Clié)
|
Quote:
And it's possible that downloading doesn't get prosecuted because copyright laws mention numbers of copies--making less than 10 copies may not be illegal, and so a single download isn't prosecutable. (Criminal copyright infringement in the US requires 10+ copies, so a single download isn't a crime. I'm less certain about how the civil laws work.) |
|
03-18-2010, 12:24 PM | #13 | |
Banned
Posts: 2,094
Karma: 2682
Join Date: Aug 2009
Device: N/A
|
Quote:
In some countries, the Rule of the Shorter Term would apply, but the USA does not recognise this. Last edited by DawnFalcon; 03-18-2010 at 12:31 PM. |
|
03-18-2010, 02:30 PM | #14 |
Addict
Posts: 266
Karma: 1378
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Seattle / San Carlos, Sonora, Mexico
Device: Kindle & WiFi Nook & PocketBook IQ
|
So I searched for "Lady Chaterley's Lover" - its is NOT in my public library. And I was somewhat curious what all the uproar is or was.
It was not in Gutenberg or Gutenberg Canada - I suspect because the copyright is still in force there. I found it in Australia. And not on the dark nets. So I guess copyright is shorter there. Now complicate the picture. First I am a US citizen. Second, it is winter - so I am living in Mexico. I downloaded the eBook in Mexico from Australia. Whose laws apply? |
03-18-2010, 03:13 PM | #15 |
Banned
Posts: 2,094
Karma: 2682
Join Date: Aug 2009
Device: N/A
|
You're in Mexico. Mexico's.
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Full HST (up to 15%) being charged on E-Books in Canada (books are 5% GST only) | Ellie Kennard | General Discussions | 18 | 07-30-2010 07:38 AM |
DRM protected Mobipocket books? | helten | Bookeen | 11 | 07-17-2008 07:59 AM |
Should Software be Protected by Patent, or by Copyright? | NatCh | News | 15 | 05-23-2007 02:12 PM |
DRM-protected e-books: Which format is right? | Alexander Turcic | News | 43 | 11-07-2006 09:34 PM |