Quote:
Originally Posted by Nyssa
But "Classic" in itself limits ones choices...so there is still an increase in the chance of having something labeled as "classic". The fact that all of the genres can also have something "classic" strengthens my case :
January
Wild Card (no nominations, a vote of all the non-winning nominations from the last 11 months)
Classic - 1; Non Classic -1
February
Romance
Classic - 2; Non Classic -2
March
Nonfiction
Classic - 3; Non Classic -3
April
Humor
Classic - 4; Non Classic - 4
May
Classic
Classic - 5; Non Classic - 4
June
Thriller/Suspense
Classic - 6; Non Classic - 5
July
Fantasy (trees/magic)
Classic - 7; Non Classic -6
August
Free For All (any genre)
Classic - 8; Non Classic - 7
September
Mystery/Crime
Classic - 9; Non Classic - 8
October
Horror
Classic - 10; Non Classic - 9
November
Science Fiction (rivets/science)
Classic - 11; Non Classic -10
December
Classic
Classic - 12; Non Classic -10
12 to 10 = Advantage = unequal opportunity.
|
You could do this with any category though, so the argument is a fallacy.
For instance, let us take sci-fi. You could have a sci-fi romance, a sci-fi comedy, a sci-fi classic, and so on, but you can't have a non-sci-fi sci-fi book. So the advantage will always be against the "non" regardless of category in this type of argument.