Hmmm, now I'm really confused. I thought this whole thread started as an attempt by you to create a reading list for you to read and document what you had read???
Anyway, carry on. I guess though if this is another attempt to create a generic 'must read' it may still be a worth effort but there are many out there already.
And at least in my case I have a significant TBR list that is at least partially comprised of recommendations from existing lists. It's also constantly changing.