Originally Posted by Mims
I'm the one who wanted thriller/suspense instead of mr library. I wouldn't object to having historical fiction in place of <1999. Might make the list more attractve to a larger group.
Problem is, if we dump not modern fiction, then modern fiction makes little to no sense to have so that would have to be dumped as well. So we'd then have to change two categories instead of just one. However, we could change not modern fiction MR Library and modern fiction for historical fiction (written 2000 or later) but the subject matter can be about any time at all.
I think we'd have to have a vote on this if the list wins as is since I don't know how many who are voting for this list want to change things.