Barbara Anna Marjanovic wrote an essay (http://www.useless-knowledge.com/1234/new/article134.html) on why people, including the author herself, are so resistant to e-books. Interesting read, although I don't agree with her in every point.

Yes, I *can* cuddle up with my PDA, drink a hot chocolate, and even enjoy reading an e-book novel. :crowngrin

She's clearly not a Clie owner (ie jog-dial user), and hasn't figured out that most pda text readers have auto-scrolling....

Her little treatise reminds me of last Christmas when I told my uncle's local bookstore owner (town of 1k ppl in the Hudson Valley) that 'I don't read paper books anymore'.

She looked like I had forewarned her of the apocalypse. :)


I'm all for donating paper books though. There are people who could really use 'em.

I like some books better in paper, but not novels or fun reading that goes from start to finish in sequence. I need paper for things that I go back and forth in, and need to scan out of order. Of course, hyperlinks and quick jumps are making that sort of thing easy in things like Bibles and reference books already!

As far as novels, I can cuddle up with a drink and my PDA book reader a lot easier than with a paperback that is harder to hold and requires two hands when turning pages! I use my thumb to click the up/down button on my PDA to turn pages. I don't have to move at all, and it "feels cool"!

...And ebooks don't cause me allergies from dust like old books and library books do.
...And try fitting a library of 10-20,000 classics on your bookshelf. Even interior designers should be thrilled with ebooks!

I'm sorry but I really hated this essay.
Needless to say, it would take a real life altering incident for people to change from their creature habit of paperback reading to e-book reading. E-book reading--sounds strange, huh?
What is she talking about?

And... is people resistant to eBooks? I think eBooks are digging their way. Download a P2P client and play a little, you'll find many people who have been through life altering incidents.
Also, who's keeping ereader, mobipocket, and such on business? Is Gutenberg project a huge waste of time, then?

I think what is so hard to handle about ebooks is that people like something to show for their spent money. You spend $5-20 on an ebook and you just get a 300kb file. Some of my emails are bigger than that. I only started reading ebooks becuase I moved to japan for two years and I was tired of paying $11 for a 300 page paperback book, and then when I move back home I didnt want a pile of books. Im one of those people who dont dog ear pages and never sell books. So it was kinda a life altering event that turned me onto ebooks. I will miss paper books but ebooks have too much going for them. I think it will take a looooong time for ebooks to catch on but I think they will replace paperback books. But I do agree with Bob. Some books need to stay in paper.

I use and love BOTH digital AND paper books! Both formats have their pros and cons. I use my medical reference ebooks constantly at work. I also like having something entertaining / distracting to read wherever I happen to be.

:indian_ch --ryan

I'm not impressed with this essay. She hasn't even tried curling up with an ebook. And if she thinks that you have to use your pen to scroll the pages, she needs to do a little more research. And as a snide aside, she may have a technology-laden house, but she hasn't yet learned how to use the spellcheck...

I've seen this before. Many people that post essays like this really haven't done their research (though they may think they have). It's annoying....

Craig.

Although I personally enjoy reading news and articles on my Zire 71 via Plucker and Sunrise, I don't think I have the attention span to read an entire ebook. On the other hand, I prefer an audio book, via Audible instead since I can listen to the book while I'm doing whatever, commuting, etc.

I guess it's not the same reading something in a hard copy format like a newsapaper or a physical book as opposed to viewing it in electronic format, like a computer screen, PDA whether it's online or from the hard drive. It's a personal thing. Although, there has been a conversion of the "printed" newspaper format available online nowadays, it almost still isn't the same. But, I do like the printed format of the newspaper as opposed to the online layout of most internet newspaper sites.

I think if they really want the ebook idea to work or make it become more popular, they really need to drop the price. I personally can't justify paying about the same price for an ebook when I can get the hardcopy at a bookstore. A book still looks nice on a shelf and gives me a feel of physical ownership. It costs the publishers way less to create an ebook (no paper, printing costs) yet the price of ebooks are too expensive in my view, even with all the constant discounts at offered at Palm Digital Media or Fictionwise.

If I wanted an ebook I'd search through Memowise or Project Gutenberg first. Or, like I mentioned already, pay for my Audible copy, if available.

I think what is so hard to handle about ebooks is that people like something to show for their spent money. You spend $5-20 on an ebook and you just get a 300kb file.

You're exactly right. I seem to remember a similar thing happening when software started to be digitally distributed. People (myself included) preferred to have the box, a disc, a printed manual, etc., as opposed to a file. Now, I find it really odd when a vendor insists on sending out an update on disc. It's just one more thing to keep up with.

Having said that, my wife is a bibliophile (for print, anyway). She loves the feel of the paper, the cover, etc. The only exception is audiobooks for the car. I'm hoping that I can eventually convert her when I finally get a reader.

What I take away from this essay is the resistance is due to lack of knowledge as demonstrated by the author herself.

There's abundantly apparent advantages and disadvantages to both paper and electronic media. Nobody can tell where's it's all going to go.

I don't see paper books being obsolete in my lifetime.
Nor do I see the eBook bubble bursting and all the readers etc becoming useless tech.

What could happen is... Kindle gets dropped, Sony stop producing them, Apple never get around to it, very few books are released in electronic editions, the market is left to niche producers like Bookeen etc.

Or both mediums could coexist, overall more books are read as people now have a choice over what medium they use. The paper book market is not negatively impacted, the electronic book market matures and develops, Kindle is not alone as a wireless device able to grab content any time.

Or.. we could see mass market paperbacks dying a death. Certain genres all but vanish. Books disappear from supermarkets, "book supermarkets" like Waterstones, Booksamillion etc close. Almost every mobile phone (cellphone for Americans) comes as standard with a roll-out electronic ink attachment. Convergence devices really kick off. It doesn't matter if you want to pay for an electronic ink device or not, or if you want an MP3 player in your phone, or if you want a phone on your MP3 player. Fact is you'll get them all in one because there's almost no cost to add the functionality to your device. Every semester students get the book list delivered to their device, they press the "accept" button and they have all their coursebooks in their device. Your morning paper arrives not through the letterbox with a slam, it arrives with a ping on your device.

Nobody knows where it's all going to go. Nobody can know. So any articles predicting anything are just basing future developments on their own opinion of things. But still, they're somewhat interesting to read.

True in the short run who knows how the details will work out. In the long run though more and more reading is going to be done electronically rather than on paper. It's just a matter of the technology advancing, becoming cheaper, and more widespread and people getting comfortable with it.

When will the switch to electronic being mainstream and paper being specialty happen, will it be a fast or slow switch, 2 years or 20? Who knows. Eventually the kids will say to their parents "You mean you actaully carried around thick, heavy books printed on paper? To get a book you had to drive to a store or library and hope they had a copy? You even kept giant shelves of them in your house? How bizzare mom."

The resistance is like the resistance to any change. It's something new and unknow and thus causes discomfort. Paper is old and well understood and people are comfortable with it but eventually change will happen. When kids grow up and their school books are all electronic do you think they'll want to load up with a bunch of heavy paper volumes for their pleasure reading? At that point paper books won't make any sense to them.

what bothers me is that so many people say that they don't like ebooks because they couldn't stand to read off "a screen." There will always be people who will prefer paperbacks, but I wish those people were educated at least!

Binzer, That's my point on people being resistant to change. For many they simply don't know what the new thing is, how it works, what it has to offer, so the easist thing to do is to stick to what they know. Throw in a bit of "if it ain't broke don't fix it" thinking and you end up with comments like "I'll never read off a sceen." Well never is a very long time. I think many would be pleasantly surpised at the current state of ereaders much less what will be available in 5-10 years. Don't bet too much money on "never".

Well there's two groups of resistance imo. There is educated resistance, and non-educated. For example, there are people who still refuse to use e-mail under any circmustance because they feel it is impersonal (even though they know all the advantages).

I figure it's the same with ebooks. There are people who know all the advantages but stubbornly stick to exclusively paper, and then people who are just ignorant and pretend like e-reading sucks although they don't really know. Although there are definitely more of the latter currently, I'm sure there will always be more of the former :)

Sure there will always be holdouts for various reasons. Ponder this though, I see the day coming when the standard Amazon store lists the electronic book and the specialty store is for the paper book. I also see the days of the physical bookstore being numbered. How many record stores still exist? How many dvd rental stores are still around? The change will come. I just can't tell you when.

What's this continuous talk about "cuddling up"?
How many muscles are necessary to keep a heavyweight like Harry Potter open AND in a slant that lets you read it.
Reading on a PDA is a whole lot easier as far as the "cuddle up" factor goes.
I haven't read in bed until I started with ebooks!

The rest of the essay is just crap. It sounds like a desperate attempt to explain her own unwillingness to go digital.

As for her not owning an ebook of her own book ... did she type it with a typewriter?

The future of bookstores could be, that you walk into a bookstore, check out the covers in a sort of Wurlitzer, or pseudo-books with excangeable covers, and then use some kind of mechanism to get the book beamed to your phone, PDA or ebook reader.
I'd like that! Because even with "Cover Flow" (© Apple Inc) you just cant beat the browsing sensation you have when you walk through a bookstore.

I agree I like browsing in bookstores but I really doubt it will be worth it for a store owner to pay for a physical store just so a few people can browse there. I could see small specialty or used book stores lasting but not the big Borders/Barnes and Noble types. I can already buy books and even download free ones right on my Kindle from anywhere with a sprint signal. Why even bother to get out of my lounge chair on the beach :-) People are already very comfortable buying and browsing for books online.

Years ago I used to browse for hours in record stores. At that time I could never fathom that they would go away. I've not been to one in years now and can only think of places like Walmart and a small shop in the mall that even carry cds anymore. My entire cd collection is ripped to my hard drive and the physical cds are in boxes in my garage just wasting space. I guess Virgin still cd stores? All the other big ones around here closed.

I totally agree on your the cuddle up comments. Anyone who doesn't think they can cuddle up with an ereader has not tried it. I wouldn't want to cuddle up with a laptop computer but then I wouldn't want to read a book on a laptop computer either.

About the only point she makes that is valid is the one about reading "Green Eggs and Ham." While my 4 yr old LOVES the idea of me reading him a story off my Cybook, he really wants to see the pictures. Current ebook readers aren't quite there yet. For a small child, colourful pictures make a big difference, the PDA screen is too small for this and I'm not willing to read a book with my son from the laptop! Until we have a larger screen with colour pictures the youngest readers will be happiest with pbooks.

However, I know my son will be switching over to an ebook reader just as soon as he learns to read books without pictures! I will probably give him my Cybook and by the newest best one for myself at that point. :D

I had communication with Ms. Marjanovic over this article. Things got heated enough that I won't post either part of the conversation, but I find it interesting to note that her 2004 opinion decried the need to be tied to a clunky laptop or immoveable desktop for reading, yet she clearly didn't fight hard enough for ebook device-independence enough to have her publisher release her books in either eReader, Mobipocket or Kindle formats. Nope. They're in, of all things, Adobe PDF format. Oops! And while they're quite reasonably priced, they're only available on BooksOnBoard (as far as I can find out).

So while she states her views have changed, she's not acting on that change of view.

Derek

Derek:
Kudos for actively conversing with the author of that spurious article. So many of these type of musings just make me shake my head. Things are really great with neat technology and all the promise of our shiny, jet-pack future, but really I am a luddite, but I want to keep that quiet, so I'll merely rail against how technology is impinging on my worldview, couching it in such terms that I just sound like a fuddy-duddy, which seems more forgivable than being an implacable moron.

Based on interactions on a thread here, I think the one about TOR free content, tracked down an author whom I admire and asked him his opinion of our coming Digital Overlords. While he expressly thanked me for supporting his lifestyle, and while lauding every possible technological advance in the world of pleasure sailing, he called everyone who downloads or purchases a digital text a potential crook. Said author will only release electronic forms of his manuals when absolutely forced to, and sees such formats as too tempting for all the lowlifes(lowlives?) out therer with internet access.
Such a brilliant technical mind, and the guy acts like the people WHO PAID FOR HIS BOAT want nothing but to rip him off.
Absolutely amazing.

As for embracing new formats, am nearly to the point that I refuse to read from those big bundles of paper with ink printed on them. Find my SONY Reader so much more cozy and convenient. When they make a colour, coffee-table sized Reader, will be pleading with "The Warden" to get one.