View Full Version : Which one?


Ancalagon
11-14-2007, 09:54 AM
First of all, sorry about my english. I'm here to ask for help. I'm interested to buy a device that allow me to read e-bbok, PDF in first place. I had found 2 model that I think can be good for my intention. The fist one is iLiad of IRex. It's beautiful, and the Wacon pen ... the only thing that I dislike is battery. I had read that I can read no more than 5 or 6 hour. This is a bad point for iLiad. The good thing is that I can write notes on my pdf like chracters profile, how is how and notes. The second one is CyBook 3 (Bookeen). 300 euro, e-book reader only. But the battery? Now, what I0m searching is a device that allow me to read e-book, but I must be sure for battery. 6h is nothing in a travel in train. At least 12.

I know that iLiad us a LinuxOS, and this is e great point for this device because I LOVE linux! So, if you have some idea of what device can be good for me, I'll be greatfull to thank you.

DaleDe
11-14-2007, 11:17 AM
First of all, sorry about my english. I'm here to ask for help. I'm interested to buy a device that allow me to read e-bbok, PDF in first place. I had found 2 model that I think can be good for my intention. The fist one is iLiad of IRex. It's beautiful, and the Wacon pen ... the only thing that I dislike is battery. I had read that I can read no more than 5 or 6 hour. This is a bad point for iLiad. The good thing is that I can write notes on my pdf like chracters profile, how is how and notes. The second one is CyBook 3 (Bookeen). 300 euro, e-book reader only. But the battery? Now, what I0m searching is a device that allow me to read e-book, but I must be sure for battery. 6h is nothing in a travel in train. At least 12.

I know that iLiad us a LinuxOS, and this is e great point for this device because I LOVE linux! So, if you have some idea of what device can be good for me, I'll be greatfull to thank you.

If you are only interested in PDF then iLiad is the best available. The typical PDF is page oriented and needs a large screen. The iLiad has must better battery life in the new version 2 device. It will do what you want while traveling on a train.

Both iLIad and CyBook use Linux but at this time only iLiad lets you get to the OS level and do Linux things.

Dale

igorsk
11-14-2007, 12:35 PM
Sony Reader runs Linux too.

Ancalagon
11-14-2007, 12:54 PM
I'm interested in e-book in general but most of my manuals or book are in PDF format. I had found some page on the net where some user of iLiad say that the battery has a poor life, somethig like 5 o 6 hour. Some person say that 60% iLiad have a problem whit wiFi and suck all the battery... I happy to read that is some software for iLiad... but I'm unsure

tribble
11-14-2007, 01:11 PM
The iLiad 2.0 should at least give you 10 hours. Up to 15 if you are just reading.
WiFi works fine as long as you dont need special encryption. It works with WEP and WPA TKIP2.

And it has the largest screen available, and is the only device that can zoom into PDFs so far.

CyBook and Sony are smaller, but their battery lasts much longer. So it mainly depends on your needs ;)

wallcraft
11-14-2007, 01:19 PM
The latest iLiad's have a larger battery, which lasts at least 10-12 hours.

Note that no current E-Ink device will read Adobe secure e-books. The Sony PRS-505 MIGHT be able to read these when the announced Adobe Digital Editions software upgrade becomes available.

Adobe's own PDF reader also no longer reads e-books, so if Adobe Reader version 8 (e.g. on Windows) can't read your documents then neither can the iLiad.

Ancalagon
11-14-2007, 01:23 PM
How moch life had a CyBook or a Sony reader?

NatCh
11-14-2007, 01:25 PM
How moch life had a CyBook or a Sony reader?The new Sony PRS505's battery goes 2~3 weeks without a charge, I think the Cybook Gen3 is similar.

tribble
11-14-2007, 01:26 PM
How moch life had a CyBook or a Sony reader?
You can measure in weeks ;)
My CyBook is loosing about 20% battery in 24hours, if i leave the autoshutdown function off, but thats just an estimate. Havent had it long enough yet.

tompe
11-14-2007, 01:29 PM
With the autoshutdown function off and the reader on the whole time my Cybook lasted 5 days.

Ancalagon
11-14-2007, 01:41 PM
So... iLiad is a tresure, of what I had seen is beautiful. The bad thing is battery, only 10hour. I mean, is not bad, I shall not read every day 10 hours, but if I read 3 hour today and knowing that tomorrow I shall go out whit friend in a travel of 6 hour... so... CyBook3 or Sony. Now this is the question. I know where I can find CyBook3, for Sony I hadn't look yet. Between this two... why I must prefer one from another? Batteryu here isn't a problem. And now... WHICH ONE?

DaleDe
11-14-2007, 03:18 PM
So... iLiad is a tresure, of what I had seen is beautiful. The bad thing is battery, only 10hour. I mean, is not bad, I shall not read every day 10 hours, but if I read 3 hour today and knowing that tomorrow I shall go out whit friend in a travel of 6 hour... so... CyBook3 or Sony. Now this is the question. I know where I can find CyBook3, for Sony I hadn't look yet. Between this two... why I must prefer one from another? Batteryu here isn't a problem. And now... WHICH ONE?

You have already been told all of the data. You will have to decide for yourself. iLiad is more like 15 hours if you are careful by the way.

Dale

JSWolf
11-15-2007, 07:14 AM
So... iLiad is a tresure, of what I had seen is beautiful. The bad thing is battery, only 10hour. I mean, is not bad, I shall not read every day 10 hours, but if I read 3 hour today and knowing that tomorrow I shall go out whit friend in a travel of 6 hour... so... CyBook3 or Sony. Now this is the question. I know where I can find CyBook3, for Sony I hadn't look yet. Between this two... why I must prefer one from another? Batteryu here isn't a problem. And now... WHICH ONE?
Since you plan to purchase an eink based device for primarily reading PDF, then you will be very unhappy with both the 505 and the Gen3. The 6" screen is not all that good for PDF reading without using a program such as pdflrf to enhance the PDF. The iLiad is really your only choice.

nekokami
11-15-2007, 09:00 AM
The battery problems you heard about on the iLiad (5-6 hours) were fixed with a software patch. The wifi was turning on when it should not.

I get about 12 hours per charge with my first version iLiad (old, smaller battery). I think 15 hours with the new battery is a good estimate. If you want to be able to make notes on your PDFs you really need the iLiad.

If you want to see what the screens will look like, try cutting holes in cardboard to match the screen size. Put the hole over an A4 page. This is how much text you will be able to see. Try photocopying the page to reduce size until it fits the rectangle. Are you happy with the result? If so, you can buy that size screen.

The iLiad has the best support for PDF right now, with zoom, pan, and continuous pages, and the largest screen.

Ancalagon
11-16-2007, 11:51 AM
I had think about it... and is true. I'm a little afraid about battery of iLiad but CyBook and SonyReader have both a small display. So, I shall buy an iLiad. I'm almost sure but I have some question about take notes and other things.

1. The motes for me is a good thing because when I read a book biger than 1000 pages where I find a lots od characters I take always notes about how-is-how. So, can i jump between my e-book and notes whitout problems? I mean, I need a sort of "paper" where I write that Bob is brother of Sam, Jane is the mother of Minni. Maibe I can write it directly in the book, don't know.

2. I love reading, but I love write too, so iLiad is a good thing another time =). But, in which format the notes are saved? JPEG? Can I transfer the notes on pc and read it?

3. I really don't know if this is possible, but, can I convert my notes (handfree) in a regular font? Why this question. In a page I had seen some picture, whitout explanation, where I had seen a document on the left in handfree taken from iLiad and on the right the same word and text in arial.

nekokami
11-16-2007, 11:54 AM
Jumping between your book and a notepad is not currently supported, but several of us think it would be a good idea, and the developer community may be able to add this functionality.

Notes are saved in .png, and can be easily read on the pc.

There is software sold by iRex that is supposed to convert notes to text. I haven't tried it yet-- someone else will need to comment on that.

Ancalagon
11-16-2007, 02:01 PM
So, if I want to note how-is-how I can only write it into the e-book while I'm reading. Hm... Ok

HarryT
11-16-2007, 02:04 PM
Yes - it's specifically an annotation feature for the document you're currently reading.

tirsales
11-16-2007, 02:13 PM
Hmm .. rather stupid idea, and of course totally OT, but:
would it be possible to add an empty margin at the bottom of the pages (pdf-to-margined-pdf) and use this as "notepad" (scrolling down to write, up to read) but while reading just skip it?
It of course wouldn't be as good as a real notepad (e.g. notes would appear only on one page). Alternatively: Is jumping backwards (to the last page) and back to the previous page possible? Then just add a couple of empty pages at the end / front / wherever (e.g. adding a link at each page-bottom, and a "back" button on the empty pages)

DaleDe
11-16-2007, 02:13 PM
Yes - it's specifically an annotation feature for the document you're currently reading.

One of the more interesting items that takes advantage of this limitation is mentioned in the iLiad forums. People are now designing documents as templates for note taking.

Dale

Ancalagon
11-16-2007, 02:39 PM
Hm...I see. A side-sliding-page where someone can get direct access to notepad to write something about what he's just reading.. really good idea. I'm so sad that I haven't the knowledge of a programmer....

nekokami
11-17-2007, 06:56 PM
One way to do this would be to allow the iLiad to display two application windows at once. I'd love to have this functionality. This would require hacking the ContentLister (proprietary code) or replacing it. There have been some community developer efforts to replace the ContentLister, but no results yet.

DaleDe
11-17-2007, 06:59 PM
One way to do this would be to allow the iLiad to display two application windows at once. I'd love to have this functionality. This would require hacking the ContentLister (proprietary code) or replacing it. There have been some community developer efforts to replace the ContentLister, but no results yet.

A split page would be an excellent addition. Lots of things it would help with.

nekokami
11-17-2007, 07:07 PM
A quick-switch function between two open applications would also work well, if that would be easier to implement. I'd be happy with either one.

DaleDe
11-17-2007, 07:30 PM
A quick-switch function between two open applications would also work well, if that would be easier to implement. I'd be happy with either one.

Probably pretty tough if both applications were the reader. I was thinking about two books, not two applications.

Dale

nekokami
11-17-2007, 10:52 PM
It ought to be possible to run two instances of a single application, but I was thinking of running the Notes application simultaneously with iPDF or FBReader.